Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

25 replies [Last post]

15. May 2006 - 18:03

#11

Offline

Joined: Oct 2005

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

Mom, Dad, and Sis.

This should be handled by clan-leaders prior to clanwar. Are we kidding now.

15. May 2006 - 19:29

#12

Offline

Joined: Feb 2006

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

wrote:

Mom, Dad, and Sis.

This should be handled by clan-leaders prior to clanwar. Are we kidding now.

Hm... yes, but the point is to have an unbiased outside party to 'monitor' the events of the CW, not to arrange/schedule/organize and so forth.

My nominations: Term, Drill, Mowly, Firefox, Goddam, Casa, Seal, (Hyper) Dragon, Saint, Enter*X, Foksie, Budman, Biohazard, Marcus, HQ, 1337, Starless, Rena, Wax...

but perhaps the choice should be left up to the clanleaders -- agreed upon by both beforehand? Ah, what a mess.

NVidia GeForce 8400GS
Logitech MX510
Hyperglide Teflon Skates
Steelpad QcK+
iHome IH-K200MB
SB Live! 5.1 Platinum
Logitech Precision Gaming Headphones
Insignia 32" HDTV

15. May 2006 - 21:12

#13

Offline

Joined: Aug 2004

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

wrote:

Mom, Dad, and Sis.

This should be handled by clan-leaders prior to clanwar. Are we kidding now.

your mom or mine?

15. May 2006 - 22:00

#14

Offline

Joined: Nov 2003

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

SuperBo! wrote:

wrote:
omg I just figured out that this topic is a reflection of ppls ambitions, from real life to be someone important. bah.

I kinda get the same impression

15. May 2006 - 22:47

#15

Offline

Joined: Jan 2006

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

wrote:

madbringer

Wow, i didn't thought i've earned enough trust to ppl try and put some responsibility in my hands here already

I'm humbled, but i don't have the time to pick up a position as a cw ref. Heh, well, thx anyway, i got all warm and fuzzy inside And if i manage some extra time, and this idea won't die by then, i would be happy to become a ref.

15. May 2006 - 23:54

#16

Offline

Joined: Feb 2006

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

I don't know any of the nominees except for term and i think he's a given anyway. IMO there's no need for a vote as far as he's concerned. but i'm just a n00b so i'll shush now

"No eternal reward will forgive us now for wasting the dawn"

16. May 2006 - 1:39

#17

Offline

Joined: Mar 2005

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

i dont see my name here

j/k

-->Excessive comes from learning the advantages and disadvantages of each weapon, what weapon is called for in different situations, and what works best against each weapon in the hands of opponents<-- All Other Is Brainless Shooting

16. May 2006 - 6:05

#18

Offline

Joined: Sep 2004

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

i dont need referees. Why i dont want truble. Some canditates have problem with time zones. I remmebert i have truble whit somebody (i mean cw date), so i dont wannt match with this person like referee. In cup oke, i agree but in rank cw i dont wanna ref.

16. May 2006 - 7:58

#19

Offline

Joined: Nov 2005

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

wrote:

for what a referee is needed:

the lack is there, that people dont know how to arrange a war:

If people clear up this points before war...

Time: date and time in gmt http://wwp.greenwichmeantime.com

Matchtype: rank or for fun

Gametype: tdm, freeze, ctf

Players: max. and min players each team (5/5 : 3/3)

Timelimit: 10 min for example

Server:

Password:

Maps: map team 1, map team 2, plus tie-map dm6 (default)

Punkbuster: enabled

Pure Server: enabled

Friendly fire: enabled (not for ctf)

Delay Time: 15 min (team comes later, forfeit win/lost or just repeat war

... than no referee is needed.

if this things are cleared up before war, u dont need any referee, and this system worked great for 2!S (expectec ko, where i came 10 min to late)

we plan each war for minimum 1 week, and we had basicly never a prob.

- what happens, if no referee is available on a fix date?
- what happens, if a team dont agree with a special referee?

I dont want to have to look for a referee, before i can arrange a war.

its much easier if clans learn how to arrange a war, instead to have complicated referees.

Damn, this is no league, its just a rank

(i have nothing against leagues, i would 2!S register as first for a league if there would be one, but ranking is no fucking league)

I agree with Your post complitly. In 99% You dont will have any trouble playing CWs. But always stay that 1%. After all referee is not need to be obligate, but optional. Ithnik that we discus things about referees. Please read topic about referees For experianced people like You, referee is not solution or need.

Best regards.

SO, I decide to lock this topic until we find out what people think about referees, let people decide do we need them. If people vote for and need it then I unlock this topic again. LETS PEOPLE VOTE AND SPEAK !

[/]

BBSQUAD CLAN
- All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die...

29. May 2006 - 9:20

#20

Offline

Joined: Nov 2005

Posts:

Nominations for Clan Ranking Referees

Referees :!:

Referee is not obligate for ranking. If one clan ask for refere other must obey. Details wos posted in rules. Rules changed.
Now I need at least list of 5 referees just in case that some clan ask for one. Everybody agreed that will be fine that clans dont call for referee and CW played smooth. But as You know, sometime we have troubles. For that cases we will provide referees.
They not actualy judges. They are just eye witnesses and colect demos and log from CW.
Here in this topic we have proposed people. I need people wich have common trust in E+ comunity and good will to help, neutral one.
I ask so far suggested people to speak did they accept to be referees. After that we will put list on vote.

Regards.

[/]

BBSQUAD CLAN
- All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die...